Otiz v. st. peter’s case study 159223

1) Read the case study (“Contract Violates Antitrust Laws”) on pages 100-101 in the textbook and answer the two discussion questions.

2) Write a paper (1,000-1,500 words) that addresses the discussion questions. Include a detailed rationale for your answers.

3) Prepare this assignment according to the APA guidelines found in the APA Style Guide, located in the Student Success Center. An abstract is not required.

4) This assignment uses a grading rubric. Instructors will be using the rubric to grade the assignment; therefore, students should review the rubric prior to beginning the assignment to become familiar with the assignment criteria and expectations for successful completion of the assignment.

 

Citation: Oltz v. St. Peter’s Community Hosp.,

 

 

 

 

 

 

19 F.3d 1312 (9th Cir. 1994)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Facts

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Oltz, a nurse anesthetist, brought an antitrust

 

 

 

action against physician anesthesiologists and St.

 

 

 

Peter’s

 

 

 

Community Hospital after he was terminated.

 

 

 

Oltz had a billing agreement with the hospital,

 

 

 

which provided 84% of the surgical services

 

 

 

in the rural community that it served. The anesthesiologists

 

 

 

did not like competing with the nurse

 

 

 

anesthetist’s lower fees and, as a result, entered

 

 

 

into an exclusive contract with the hospital on April

 

 

 

29, 1980, in order to squeeze the nurse anesthetist

 

 

 

out of the market. This resulted in cancellation of

 

 

 

the nurse anesthetist’s contract with the hospital.

 

 

 

Oltz filed a suit against the anesthesiologists and

 

 

 

hospital for violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act,

 

 

 

15 U.S.C. § 1. The anesthesiologists settled for

 

 

 

$462,500 before trial.

 

 

 

The case against the hospital proceeded to trial.

 

 

 

The jury found that the hospital conspired with

 

 

 

the anesthesiologists and awarded the plaintiff

 

 

 

$212,182 in lost income and $209,649 in future

 

 

 

damages. The trial judge considered the damage

 

 

 

award to be excessive

 

 

 

and ordered a new trial.

 

 

 

The hospital motioned the court to exclude all

 

 

 

damages after June 26, 1982, which was the date

 

 

 

that the hospital renegotiated its exclusive contract

 

 

 

with the anesthesiology group. The court decided

 

 

 

that Oltz failed to prove that the renegotiated contract

 

 

 

also violated antitrust laws, thus ruling that

 

 

 

Oltz was not entitled to damages after June 26,

 

 

 

1982. Because

 

 

 

Oltz conceded that he could not

 

 

 

prove damages greater than those offset by his

 

 

 

settlement

 

 

 

with the physicians, his claim for damages

 

 

 

against the hospital was disposed of by summary

 

 

 

judgment.

 

 

 

The judge who presided over Oltz’s request for

 

 

 

attorneys’ fees restricted the amount that he could

 

 

 

claim. Because Oltz had been denied damages

 

 

 

from the hospital, the judge refused to award attorneys’

 

 

 

fees or costs for work performed after the

 

 

 

1986 liability trial.

 

 

 

 

 

Issue

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Was Oltz entitled to seek recovery for all damages

 

 

 

resulting from destruction of his business after

 

 

 

June 26, 1982?

 

 

 

 

 

Holding

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

 

 

 

held that Oltz was entitled to seek recovery for all

 

 

 

damages.

 

 

 

 

 

Reason

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Oltz introduced evidence that the initial exclusive

 

 

 

contract violated antitrust laws and that such

 

 

 

violation destroyed his practice. “Because the initial

 

 

 

conspiracy destroyed his practice, Oltz is entitled

 

 

 

to seek recovery for all damages resulting from the

 

 

 

destruction of his business. . . . The legality of any

 

 

 

subsequent agreements between the conspirators

 

 

 

is irrelevant, because the April 29, 1980, contract

 

 

 

severed the lifeline to Oltz’s thriving practice. . .”

 

 

 

Discussion

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

1. What should parties to a contract be aware of

 

 

 

when negotiating exclusive contracts?

 

 

 

2. What remedies are available when one party

 

 

 

breaches a contract by refusing to perform an

 

 

 

agreed-upon service?

 

 

Get 20% Discount on This Paper
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Try it now!

Get 20% Discount on This Paper

We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:
$0.00

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Services

Custom Writings Help is a Quality-Oriented Company in Online Writing as a result of hiring exceptional professionals to execute clients' tasks.

Essays

Research Papers

At Custom Writings Help,We understand the struggle of research paper writing, and that is why at Custom WritingS Help, we are all out to help you. We pride ourselves on having a team of clinical writers. The stringent and rigorous vetting process ensures that only the 'BEST' Writers are chosen for the job. We have highly qualified Ph.D. and MA writers working with us; we equally offer these experienced writers specific bonuses and incentives to make them deliver highly original, unique, and informative content at reasonably low prices.

Admissions

Thesis Writing Service

Worlwide, Many Masters Students are struggling with Thesis Completion. A thesis is likely to be the longest and most challenging piece of work a student has ever completed. However, unlike essays and other assignments, a student can pick a particular interest topic and work on their initiative. Fortunately, we are there for you. At Custom Writings Help, you are assured of an authentic, imaginative, informative, linguistically great, and advantageous thesis that adheres to all your needs. So, why continue considering different writers when you have discovered the best in the field?

Editing

Custom Papers

Not a single student can avoid writing custom papers. However, a total lack of experience, skills, and time makes it very hard to produce a superb writing piece. Therefore, if you are seeking professional help, turn to us. Our specialized and experienced writers compose a variety of model papers, including custom essays, college term papers, research papers, book reports, MBA essays, executive summaries, dissertations, Ph.D. theses, admission essays, and research proposals for college and university students at any level.

Coursework

Essay Writing

Most of the students disregard the critical principles of essay writing and compose papers below sensible guidelines. Therefore, with Custom Writings Help, one should not worry about his/her essay. Our Writers compose informative and engaging content on all complexities and topics. We write meaningful and smart essays while prioritizing all aspects that bring about a good grade, such as impeccable grammar, proper structure, zero-plagiarism, and conformance to guidelines.

Coursework

Coourse Work Writing

Don't let the seemingly never-ending onslaught of writing assignments get you down. If you are looking where to get course work assistance online, the writers at Custom Writings Help are here to assist you with all of your writing needs. We undertake to unique delivery of papers that meet the professor's requirements. The content is proofread, edited, and checked plagiarism before submission to customers. No matter how big or small your work is, we will deliver on time. Try US Now! !

Coursework

Dissertation Writing Service

High-Quality Dissertation Writing Services are rare. They require Ph.D. academicians – not easily found. However, are an exception. The years, time, and resources we have invested in the dissertation world has given us a competitive advantage over others. Choose to come to Custom Writings Help; You will find perfect Ph.D. consultants who have written hundreds of dissertations theses ready to help you. Let our dissertation-writing services help you craft your dissertation, for you are assured we will give you the results.

Open chat